{
  "id": "ventricular-conduction-v1",
  "title": "Ventricular conduction and pacing",
  "endpoint": "electrophysiology",
  "workflow": {
    "task": "For four prespecified ventricular conduction papers, locate one reported prediction per paper, identify its evaluation source and physical PDF pages, and determine which reported findings can be compared.",
    "retrieval": "The release returned 88 prediction records across two API pages of up to 50 rows. The four selected predictions were present. The DOI filters returned one prediction each for Meiburg, Lange and Camps, and two for Tang. Use the linked prediction ID to select the intended Tang record.",
    "validation_scope": "The case provides source-page locators for evaluation context in all four papers. Camps has a linked same-source validation assessment in the prediction record. The Meiburg, Tang and Lange case entries document proposed in vivo evaluation, within-study sensitivity analysis and limited human evidence, respectively.",
    "lookup_protocol": "On 15 November 2026 UTC, we ran an endpoint search in ViBA and used the phrase ventricular activation in the three external searches. For the follow-up, we used the same four article DOIs and searched the two model repositories by full article title as well. The task was to obtain the selected prediction, its evaluation source and PDF page locators, and a pairwise decision.",
    "comparison": [
      {
        "resource": "ViBA",
        "entry": "Electrophysiology and conduction. Filter by DOI and select the predefined prediction ID.",
        "output": "Four selected prediction records with result and evaluation-context pages in the case export. The comparison shows six source-reviewed decisions."
      },
      {
        "resource": "Europe PMC",
        "entry": "Ventricular activation in title or abstract, followed by four exact DOI searches.",
        "output": "All four publications were found by DOI, with article or full-text links. The returned records provide the starting point for extracting the evidence from the papers."
      },
      {
        "resource": "BioModels",
        "entry": "Ventricular activation in model search, followed by article DOI and complete title.",
        "output": "The endpoint search returned model entries. The DOI and title lookups returned no model entry for the four selected papers."
      },
      {
        "resource": "Physiome Model Repository",
        "entry": "Ventricular activation in repository search, followed by article DOI and complete title.",
        "output": "The endpoint search returned repository items. The DOI and title lookups returned no model entry for the four selected papers."
      }
    ],
    "lookup_interpretation": "ViBA provides the source-linked predictions and evaluation context as a single comparison with reproducible locators and explicit limits. The external searches support article discovery or model discovery. This four-paper comparison describes the outputs of the recorded workflow. General search recall and repository coverage are outside its scope."
  },
  "scope": "Four existing ViBA publications selected to illustrate how different definitions of ventricular activation affect cross-study interpretation. This is a worked example with one prediction per publication.",
  "method": "Join the four prediction IDs to ViBA's publication and PDF-source tables. Match each PDF to its stored SHA-256. Count PDF pages from the first file page, including any cover. Review the cited methods, results and limitations. Compare anatomical region, weighting, clock origin, pacing or disease contrast and validation source before interpreting any numerical result.",
  "comparison_summary": "One of the six pairs supports comparison of the direction of the reported simulation results. The other five provide context only because the selected endpoints or contrasts differ.",
  "lookup_summary": "On 15 November 2026, exact DOI searches in Europe PMC found all four publications. Searches by DOI and full article title in BioModels and the Physiome Model Repository returned zero model entries for these four papers. These observations describe the specified lookups at publication and model level, respectively. Repository coverage under other search terms and comparative search performance were outside the scope of the case.",
  "rows": [
    {
      "id": "d630526c-6ece-5f98-9a2a-aec3df416cd8", "label": "Meiburg et al. (2023)",
      "model": "Human mean-shape biventricular eikonal model coupled to CircAdapt. The geometry averages 100 healthy participants; the comparisons use one virtual geometry.",
      "comparator": "Non-selective left bundle branch pacing (nsLBBP) versus right ventricular apical pacing (RVAP). The paper also models selective LBB pacing, septal, biventricular and His-bundle pacing.",
      "metric": "Regional AT-95 (ms), the time to activate 95% of myocardial mass. Results are calculated separately for the left ventricular free wall, septum and right ventricular free wall.",
      "time_window": "Electrical activation during each simulated pacing scenario, evaluated up to 95% of regional myocardial mass.",
      "result": "Left ventricular free-wall AT-95 is shorter during nsLBBP than during RVAP (Figure 5); the plotted values are used for direction only.",
      "validation": "Clinical observations informed the simulation assumptions. The authors propose future in vivo comparison of the simulated measurements. The selected AT-95 contrast has no independent validation reported in the cited passages.",
      "locations": {"Model and comparator":[3,4],"Endpoint and time window":[3,6],"Result":[5,6],"Validation source":[7,9]},
      "figure": "Figures 2 and 5"
    },
    {
      "id": "1cc73eda-e23d-5ac3-81d8-5d5afa2eff5a", "label": "Tang et al. (2026)",
      "model": "Reaction-eikonal electrophysiology in 24 anatomies with modelled proximal left bundle branch block (LBBB).",
      "comparator": "Nominal non-selective left bundle branch area pacing (LBBAP) versus right ventricular apical pacing (RVA), with a separate sinus-initiated LBBB control and proximal/distal pacing positions.",
      "metric": "BiV_TAT95 (ms), the node-weighted 95th percentile of activation times across both ventricles and the septum. The paper also reports LVAT95 for left ventricular nodes.",
      "time_window": "From stimulus time zero to the 95th percentile on the simulation clock. The first ventricular activation time is retained in that clock.",
      "result": "Nominal LBBAP versus RVA: BiV_TAT95 93.5 versus 96.5 ms and LVAT95 85.5 versus 98.5 ms (group medians, Table 3). The reported median paired reduction in BiV_TAT95 is 2.5 ms (Table 4).",
      "validation": "Within-study sensitivity analysis in three anatomies. The authors identify external patient-specific electrical validation as future work.",
      "locations": {"Model and comparator":[3,4,5,6],"Endpoint and time window":[5,6],"Result":[10,11],"Validation source":[12,13]},
      "figure": "Tables 3 and 4, Figure 7"
    },
    {
      "id": "283abf72-fe6c-54c8-956f-47bc351c7a8f", "label": "Lange et al. (2016)",
      "model": "Human eikonal virtual population with a Purkinje network. Table 4 reports 70 ventricular geometries.",
      "comparator": "LBBB without a conductive false tendon versus LBBB with a modelled direct false tendon to the ventricular free wall. Healthy geometry and alternative insertions are also tabulated.",
      "metric": "Simulated QRS duration (ms), defined as a myocardial activation-time surrogate.",
      "time_window": "From the first myocardial activation to complete myocardial activation.",
      "result": "The mean surrogate duration was 131.9 ± 9.8 ms for LBBB without a false tendon and 105.8 ± 7.1 ms with direct attachment to the ventricular free wall (Table 4).",
      "validation": "Previous literature supports the modelling approach. The authors report limited human evidence for direct validation of the false-tendon effect.",
      "locations": {"Model and comparator":[8,9,10,12],"Endpoint and time window":[10],"Result":[12],"Validation source":[18]},
      "figure": "Table 4 and Figure 6"
    },
    {
      "id": "e8eab0e2-e0cb-551e-afb4-1b541dc8dff5", "label": "Camps et al. (2024)",
      "model": "CMR-derived human biventricular digital twins with eikonal inference and monodomain simulation. Four control subjects and two subjects with hypertrophic cardiomyopathy.",
      "comparator": "Simulated versus recorded 12-lead ECG of the same subject. The paper also contrasts root-node, minimal Purkinje and full Purkinje configurations.",
      "metric": "Pearson correlation of the simulated and clinical QRS waveforms. The results also describe QRS shortening with the full Purkinje configuration.",
      "time_window": "Manually delineated QRS complex of the averaged clinical ECG (20 beats) and the corresponding simulated waveform.",
      "result": "Most eikonal configurations report waveform correlation above 0.8. The full Purkinje configuration shortened simulated QRS in the monodomain comparisons (Figure 6).",
      "validation": "Same-source comparison with clinical ECG. The target ECG is used during calibration. The selected results measure agreement with those data.",
      "locations": {"Model and comparator":[2,5,8],"Endpoint and time window":[8,10],"Result":[9,10],"Validation source":[5,8,9]},
      "figure": "Table 1 and Figures 5 and 6"
    }
  ],
  "pairs": [
    {"rows":[0,1],"status":"Direction only","reason":"In both simulations, non-selective left bundle pacing shortened the selected left ventricular activation measure relative to right ventricular apical pacing. Meiburg measured time to activate 95% of left ventricular free-wall myocardial mass in a mean-shape model derived from healthy participants. Tang measured the 95th percentile of left ventricular nodal activation times from the pacing stimulus in models of proximal left bundle branch block. Tang's separate biventricular endpoint covers a different region. Differences in region, weighting and model setting make the timing effects unsuitable for pooling. Meiburg proposed future in vivo comparison. Tang reported a sensitivity analysis and identified external validation as future work."},
    {"rows":[0,2],"status":"Context only","reason":"Both report simulated myocardial activation times. Meiburg measures time to activate 95% of regional myocardial mass under different pacing strategies. Lange measures the interval from first to complete myocardial activation under different false-tendon configurations. The anatomical region, timing definition and contrast differ."},
    {"rows":[0,3],"status":"Context only","reason":"Both concern ventricular activation. Meiburg compares pacing strategies using regional activation time. Camps uses Pearson correlation between simulated and recorded QRS waveforms from the same subject, with those recordings informing calibration. The selected results address distinct quantities and comparisons."},
    {"rows":[1,2],"status":"Context only","reason":"Both model left bundle branch block. Tang compares pacing strategies and measures a nodal activation percentile from the stimulus. Lange compares false-tendon configurations and measures the interval from first to complete myocardial activation. The timing boundaries and contrasts differ."},
    {"rows":[1,3],"status":"Context only","reason":"Both concern simulated ventricular activation. Tang compares pacing strategies using time from the stimulus to a nodal activation percentile. Camps measures waveform agreement with the same subjects' recorded ECGs, which also informed calibration. The quantity, reference and contrast differ."},
    {"rows":[2,3],"status":"Context only","reason":"The studies use QRS to describe different quantities. Lange uses a simulated first-to-complete myocardial activation interval as a duration surrogate in a false-tendon contrast. Camps uses Pearson correlation between simulated and recorded QRS waveforms. The recorded ECGs also informed calibration, so the correlation measures agreement with the calibration source. These results provide context for how QRS was used in each study."}
  ]
}
